Welcome to the place where we go beyond traditional ranking systems. Sure, you can look at the AP top-25 or the NCAA’s NET rankings. We’re diving deeper, acknowledging that the human eye can be misleading, and that data is the best way to approach predicting the madness come March. Don’t just take my word for it, take a look here where I break down exactly what the data is telling me. I will be defining teams as “vulnerable” or “impenetrable” or simply “flyers”, and exactly what backs up my logic for these can also found in that first article. For now, a synopsis: Vulnerable teams are the statistical archetype of a team that is likely to be upset the first weekend. Impenetrable teams are the antithesis of that, fitting the archetype of teams who almost never miss the Sweet 16. Finally, the flyers, teams that don’t fit those narrow barometers but find themselves in or around the top-10. So, every week we’ll take a look at Kenpom’s 10 most efficient teams and define them, look at their week (or season if they’re new) and assess where they truly stand in the Contender vs Pretender debate. The beauty of this series is it is completely reactionary week to week, but over the course of the next 6 weeks or so we are going to encapsulate the journey some of these teams take entering March. Let’s dive in.
- Houston: (17-2) Off (15) Def (1) – IMPENETRABLE
- Houston is who we thought they were. I have been waiting for weeks for them to win a tough Big 12 game and they did so heading to Provo, Utah and beating a BYU team that the data suggests is a top-10 team in the Country. They defend, they rebound, and when they’re right they have 3 guys in Shead, Cryer and Sharp who can score. They have had issues in their 2 losses scoring the basketball, but their ability to defend and get offensive rebounds has offset that for the most part. It’s still a bit concerning seeing they’re 235th in 2 pt FG %, but when you can get 15+ offensive rebounds a game then you can afford to miss some shots. I love how hard they play, I think Kelvin Sampson is a fantastic HC, I just worry about them offensively. Every team has a weakness, so at the end of the day you just have to trust the data. That suggests this Houston team should be a March Favorite.
- Purdue: (18-2) Off (1) Def (11) – IMPENETRABLE
- I said last week that an easy 2-0 week and I would be all-in on the Boilermakers, and wouldn’t you know that’s exactly what happened. Both games were very impressive wins, with a 30 point drubbing of Michigan and a 14-point win @ Iowa, holding them to just 70 points. Defensively is the side of the ball that has to be monitored for Purdue, as in their two losses they’ve given up 92 and 88. When they’re locked in and connected defensively they can be pretty good, in spite of the weakness they have with Zach Edey. Even though he can block shots, smaller teams can really expose him on closeouts and breakdown Purdue defensively. Not to mention any guards who can excel in the mid-range can tear Purdue apart in ball screen action as Edey has to play drop coverage, see Jalen Hood-Schifino last year. All of those being true, and Purdue still being a top-15 team defensively is highly impressive, and that fact along with their improvement from 3 from 32% to 40% is the reason I’m all-in on these Boilers.
- Tennessee: (14-4) Off (19) Def (2) – FLYER
- Slowly but surely we’re seeing Tennessee improve offensively and creep up towards that impenetrable territory. For now, their limitations beyond Knecht are holding them back, but I have hope due to the return of Zeigler and how much better it has looked game after game with him at the point. They absolutely man-handled Alabama in their only game since we last met, and with only a trip to Vandy and then S. Carolina at home, I don’t expect much to change between now and next week. We know they defend at an elite level, just sitting back now and monitoring how they continue to improve offensively as SEC play rolls along.
- Auburn: (16-3) (10) (5) – IMPENETRABLE
- It’s becoming clearer to me who this Auburn team is, or at least where their struggles are going to be as their schedule ramps up. They really can dominate the front-court with Broome and Williams, but their 1-3 spots are made up of a large rotation of guys who are ultimately all B players. They defend at a high level, and have a ton of versatility on that end as they can switch and all 5 guys can defend on the perimeter. They have a ton of depth as well, it’s just they don’t have that go-to scorer/playmaker in the backcourt. Their weakness is in the half-court, and while every team has a weakness, I think this one is going to continue to shine bright as SEC play rolls along. They have Tennessee, Kentucky and Alabama again still on their schedule. Plus a meeting with Mississippi St on the road up next, who is a team that can lock you down and make life miserable. Obviously Auburn is a great defensive team and has 2 bigs they can play through, but we’re going to find out just how much of a weakness this backcourt is in a hurry.
- Arizona: (14-5) Off (8) Def (12) – IMPENETRABLE
- Arizona continues to baffle me, losing to Oregon St last night and just further proving they are not to be trusted. They gave up 83 points on 68 possessions to Oregon St, yes the now 10-9 Oregon St Beavers. I get not showing up for a game or two, but we’re now up to 3 losses to teams I don’t have in the tourney. Their defensive rank has gone from 3rd to 12th over the last couple of weeks as they’ve racked up disgusting losses in the Pac-12. They can score, they play fast and share the ball, but you can’t convince me at this point this is a great defensive team. I know they’re ranked 12th, and the data suggests they are technically a team to trust in March, but with a little human context you can see they don’t play consistently well, something you have to do to win 4-6 games in a row in March. Maybe they can just turn the switch on and go on a run, but I have a feeling I won’t be forced to trust the data with Arizona come March as that defensive rank should continue to balloon unless they turn this ship around. Up next is a trip to Oregon where they could easily lose and then an easy one with Cal at home. Tick tock Arizona, I see right through you.
- UNC: (16-3) (16) (4) – FLYER
- The Tar Heels are the hottest team in the Country right now, winners of 9 in row, all by double digits and they’re now 8-0 to start ACC play. I’ve spoken at length about their turnaround before, but it’s worth noting they continue to play stifling D, which has been the biggest key to their success. RJ Davis is playing at an elite level, but the addition of Harrison Ingram might be the biggest key for this team. He is shooting 39% from 3, but more importantly, during ACC play he’s now averaging 10.6 rpg including nearly 3 offensive boards a game. His activity on the glass and versatility defensively has been a catalyst for their turnaround from a season ago. So much pressure to produce has been lifted off the shoulders of Bacot, and without lazy Caleb Love they actually are connected defensively. I would expect them to continue to rise up the rankings and enter that Impenetrable category very soon. They do have a tricky week upcoming though, with trips to a hot Florida St team and then a pesky GA Tech team on the docket, with the Duke game lying in wait. These are the survive and advance type of weeks.
- UConn: (17-2) Off (3) Def (28) – FLYER
- UConn racked up another impressive win this week going to Villanova and squeaking out a W. Donovan Clingan is back and producing, and as expected they have turned their defensive woes around with his return. His presence inside as a shot blocker is huge for them, as they can get up and put more pressure on teams knowing he’s in the middle. He also is huge for them in the rebounding department, and as we always harp on here, defensive rebounding is a huge part of defense that doesn’t always get discussed. Hard to limit teams offensively if you can’t end the possession with a board. What I’m interested to see is how much of an impact he will have overall on that end, can they work their way into a top-15 ranking? Time will tell, but in the Big East they will face multiple elite offenses, so the answer will be self-evident. Up next are 2 home games with Xavier and Providence, so the train should just keep on rolling.
- Alabama: (13-6) Off (2) Def (57) – VULNERABLE
- Bama and Nate Oats just got through their toughest week on the schedule, going to Tennessee and losing but bouncing back to beat Auburn at home. They needed that win after a bit of an egg in the Tennessee game, but I genuinely think Oats is maximizing what he has in this roster. He’s missing his key ingredient, which is an athletic front court guy that can block shots and clean up the glass. Last year it was Bediako, and they were top-5 defensively, and prior to that he had Herbert Jones when they were top-5 as well. Let me say it clearly, you can’t extend your defense and try to create havoc without that guy sitting back in the middle ready to block/alter shots. That’s the reason for that 57th ranking. They don’t clean up the glass and they give up driving lanes while over-extended without the guys inside able to block and alter shots. Proof? Auburn shot 55% from 2, while Tenn shot 58%. They’re now 157th in 2pt FG % allowed. Yes they can score, but this roster is not built to play well defensively, even if they’re giving max effort, which I thought they were the other night v Auburn. They still gave up 75 points (75 possessions) and that was with Auburn going 5-25 from 3. I don’t see Oats switching his philosophy, so I will continue to watch Bama for the fun and chaos, but come March I will be avoiding at all cost. Up next for them is a home tilt with LSU and then a trip to a pesky Georgia team.
- BYU: (14-5) (12) (23) – FLYER
- Well, the BYU experiment seems to be crashing and burning, yet somehow an 0-2 week still has them in the 9th spot for another week. They have fallen tremendously far though, from impenetrable to flyer status, which I believe more accurately depicts who this team is. They dropped a tough road game to a good Texas Tech team, but the home game v Houston is one you’d think a top-10 team could take care of. I know they’ve been dealing with injuries, and maybe in a few weeks that rotation will look back to normal and they’ll be playing much better again, but until then we have to call it like it is and they’re just 2-4 in Big 12 play. They have a bounce-back opportunity up next with Texas coming to Provo. The Longhorns have been playing better but this feels like a must-win for BYU to keep things from totally spiraling out of control.
- Illinois: (14-5) (7) (31) – FLYER
- The Illini have welcomed back Terrance Shannon Jr, for better or worse, and went 1-1 since we last met. They blew out Rutgers at home and then lost a thriller in OT @ Northwestern. Something about those Wildcats at home produces some wild games against top teams, and the Illini were just unable to stop Boo Buie. The return of Shannon will be interesting to watch, as Illinois had found some rhythm offensively without him, but it could be a great thing in the end as Domask and Harmon are now playing with much more confidence. Their 5-out approach with Hawkins and Guerrier in the front-court makes them extremely difficult to defend, and very versatile defensively. Their weakness comes on the defensive end though, as they just don’t apply much pressure and are one of the worst teams in the Country when it comes to forcing TO’s. Northwestern had just 5, for example, which allowed them to get in rhythm and get essentially whatever matchup they wanted offensively, as Illinois switches 1-5. Of course, not every team is going to go 11-18 from 3, but when you allow a guy like Buie to pick his matchup and then penetrate and breakdown the defense, you’re going to give up rhythm 3’s. That was the story, and that has been the story in their 5 losses, giving up over 1 point per possession in each. Up next, they get a meh IU team at home and then a trip to a desperate Ohio St team. A 2-0 week would be very impressive.
- Wisconsin: (15-4) (6) (47) – FLYER
- Iowa St: (13-4) (52) (3) – VULNERABLE
- Duke: (14-4) Off (9) Def (38) – FLYER
- Baylor: (14-4) (5) (62) – VULNERABLE
- Creighton: (15-5) (34) (14) – FLYER
- Michigan St: (12-7) (33) (18) – FLYER
- Marquette: (14-5) (35) (16) – FLYER
- Kansas: (16-3) (28) (25) – FLYER
- Gonzaga: (14-5) Off (26) Def (29) – VULNERABLE
- Kentucky: (14-4) (4) (96) – VULNERABLE